Autocar - First for car news and reviews

Advertisement

Top bloggers

Advertisement

Tue
Feb 19 2008

Has the C-charge started a class war?

Mike Duff

 

So Porsche is trying to get a judicial review called down on the proposed increase in London's congestion charge. First reaction: good on it - and it's a shame that other heavily affected companies (like Land Rover and Subaru) lack the guts to stick their heads above the parapet, too.

But if you're part of the 90 percent of the British population that lives outside greater London your reaction could quite possibly be one of shrugged shoulders and exhaled breath. Why, after all, does somebody need to drive their Porsche into central London between the hours of 7am and 6pm, Monday to Friday?

The thing is, this is an issue that's going to acquire a scary relevance for the rest of us - and sooner than most people realise. The technology and legislative framework for national road charging is being quietly assembled behind the scenes - and the view that vehicles with higher CO2 emissions are going to be hit disproportionately hard is in serious danger of becoming ingrained.

Put it this way - imagine that you live in Kensington and own a Porsche 911 that you keep on the road. Two years ago all you needed to do was to pay road tax and Kensington and Chelsea's resident parking fees. Then, against the wishes of the vast majority of local residents, the Congestion Charge was expanded westwards. As a bona fide resident you managed so secure the discounted rate - equivalent to 80p a day.

But now, without moving, changing your habits or doing anything other than existing, the bill for owning your car is going to increase to £25-a-day. That's a 3000 percent increase in the cost of owning a car that probably covers fewer than 5000 miles a year. This isn't a green-tinted, environmentally-focussed charge - it's class warfare.

Granted, we can't all afford to live in Kensington or own Porsche 911s - but once this framework is in place, and the link between marginally higher CO2 emissions and massively increased charges is put in place, they'll be after the rest of us soon enough. How long before the CO2 emissions of a petrol-powered Renault Scenic (192 g/km) or Mercedes E200 (195 g/km) are considered beyond the pale?

Don't expect the rest of the media to stick up for the beleagured motorist, certainly not to judge by the enthusiasm with which Transport for London's description of anything that puts out over 225 g/km of CO2 as a "gas guzzler" has been taken up.

Really? Well what about the LTI TX4 black cab? When fitted with the automatic gearbox that 99 percent of London's cabbies opt for it puts out a "gas guzzling" 233 g/km of CO2 - and yet it remains completely exempt from the congestion charge. And that's before you get on to working out how many passengers a double-decker bus has to be carrying to justify its 1600 g/km.

What's that expression again? Oh yes, blatant hypocracy.

Technorati tags: , , ,

Sign-in or register to add your comments

About Mike Duff

Used to edit this website, but now back to reporting from the road - and contemplating which sub-£1000 1990s German executive to buy next

Comments

JeremyT February 19, 2008 2:37 PM

Some good points there.  Interesting that the proposed changes are 'fuel neutral' as the hybrid exemption's to go.  I think that the early Prius are Euro 3 (?), therefore will no longer be exmept from the charge (as the discoutn is for 120g/km that are Euro 4).  Certainly the Lexus hybrid will no longer be exempt.

ZM February 19, 2008 9:27 PM

Someone PLEASE shoot, blow-up, maim, poison, strangle, run-over, just do whatever is required to that filthy ignorant jealous communist f*#k that calls himself the 'Mayor of London'!!

loather February 20, 2008 4:42 PM

Mike you've gotta use a spell-checker or get better with words of the top of your head: 'oh yes, blatant hypocracy'. Hypocrisy man!

By the way anyone who is stupid or gullible enough to believe the man-made Global Warming™ cult thing deserves all the taxes possible dumped on them. A fool and his money are soon parted. Would CO2 emissions from automobiles be the reason that planet Mars has had rising temperatures too? Damn those martians and their 4x4s!

Did you see the story last week that a moon of Saturn's, Titan, has liquid hydrocarbons? And not only is the estimated extent vast, but the rotted vegetation genesis doesn't make sense. Could the same hold for the Earth? And if so are oil reserves far greater than we're lead to believe, with all the propagandizing over 'Peak-Oil'?

Titan hydrocarbons story: saturn.jpl.nasa.gov/.../press-release-details.cfm

loather February 20, 2008 4:43 PM

Duh! '...of the top of your head'. Should have been 'off' of course!

Jon Hardcastle February 20, 2008 5:10 PM

As a car driver who pays road tax, fuel tax and emmisions tax, if the strip in front of me is paved with tarmac or concrete I am allowed to drive down it no matter what time of day it is.

Jon Hardcastle February 20, 2008 5:14 PM

And that should be without having to pay any further duty in order to do so. I am also a fully paid up member of the insurance brigade, no points, no convictions, no tax dodging of any kind.

I therefore am the type of muppet that red Ken is after.

Wayne ker.

And I don't live within 200 miles of London!!

loather February 20, 2008 5:56 PM

@ Jon Hardcastle

May be of interest to you to read this piece on Red Ken:

www.prisonplanet.com/.../022008_bottled_water.htm

The banning bottled water thing they're pushing now - it's all about getting everyone to drink tap water which will come courtesy of the Govt. with 'medicinal' flouride. Flouride is proven to addle the brain - has been used in the past to 'pacify' prisoners. "Get the b*stards dumbed down and they'll believe any of this Green cr*p!"

jer February 22, 2008 8:44 AM

I couldn’t give a monkeys if he taxes the cajones off every non dom or multi millionaire property owner and Porsche drivers in the congestion zone. I have never had to pay it I drive into London at Weekends and most week days take the train.

It's refreshing to see a balancing in the class war after thirty years of ascendancy for the mega rich. I see little problem. If it starts to effect the layman he will be voted out.

Perhaps the blog should be aimed at the pernicious pricing of Porsche UK now that is an issue that Mr Duff you should be promoting in your blog - price equality with US Porsche dealers.  

Matt Saunders February 22, 2008 2:38 PM

Jer,

If you were a more regular reader of the estimable Mr Duff's blogs, you'd know that he wrote about the very subject of US/UK price inequality only the other week.

I humbly refer you, and anyone else interested in finding out how severely us Brits are ripped off on new cars, to the below:

www.autocar.co.uk/.../want-a-cheap-vw-move-to-the-usa.aspx

Nuff said, I think you'll agree.

JJBoxster February 22, 2008 9:48 PM

Jer  & Matt Sanders

If you're advocating better prices why aren't you on your high-horses over cheaper American fuel as well?

And  if you want a class war I'd suggest your country would go backwards into a Third World quicker than you ever imagined with industry, sceince and entrepeneurs mising.. otherwise I suggest you keep your insidious little chips out of democracy which is no place for fairly representing and respecting all our citizens.

Finally if you, like Red Ken wish to use democratic machinery to make people poorer can I suggest you put that in a manifesto and see how you get on? At the moment I think alot of people are dying to get to the ballot box (only 1 in 5 Londoners voted this idiot in).

All CO2 taxes will go into green issues will they? I think Red Ken will join Gordon 'hash' Brown and have 'green taxes' that don't go into 'green things' but just help to balance their crumbling books. That's deceipt of the highest order.

JJBoxster February 22, 2008 9:56 PM

Matt Sanders - sorry, don't know how I inc your name alongside the 'inaccurate' Mr. Jer. My apologies.

Was going to say I've owned 3 Porsche and my last 2 were imported from Germany so I don't support Porsche UK too much. However you shouldn't cut off your nose to spite your face and this action by Porsche has integrity and common sense written all over it. I've signed their petition and hope many others do too:

www.porschejudicialreview.co.uk

michael knight March 6, 2008 10:32 PM

Sad to say, judging by the idiotic 'red-ken' red-top comments of the above, you'll have racist-toff Boris in and Rolls-Royce's will drive for free in old-boy Etonian London. It's not class-warfare, it's a road to making central London car-free in several years, and a much better place it'll be for it too.

Austinruby7 March 9, 2008 10:17 PM

God help you Londoners with the sodding congstion charge. The sooner you vote that tosser Livingstone out, the better. But I suspect our other cities will follow his thinking. On a different note I ask any prat standing for election who comes to my door if he will support getting sleeping policemen on the roads in my area. If he or she says yes they are quickly invited to leave!!

All about Autocar

Newsfeeds

Subscribe to our news with our RSS feeds

Advertise

To advertise with Autocar contact us

Buy our magazines

Discover our titles at themagazineshop.com

Autocar latest issue - Cover 07 Jan

NEW ISSUE OUT NOW

FAST, EASY & SECURE
SUBSCRIBE NOW>>