8

The new-generation Q5 has underwhelmed, but a 362bhp sports version is another matter

Our testing of the new-generation Audi Q5 has highlighted a slip in class standards for the mid-sized SUV.

That the best-in-class model scores no higher than three-and-a-half stars says plenty about progress being made, or rather not being made, by the breed, the bread-and-butter Q5 itself notable only really for being new rather than any kind of leap forward.

In that context, it’s hard to get too excited by the Audi SQ5 performance version, the type of go-faster car that can typically push a middling breed in a direction that simply compromises it further.

Which admittedly is unlikely to make you too excited about the words to come on this page. Yet your eyes will probably already have already caught site of the rating at the top of the page: yep, four stars, and the SQ5 reveals itself to have plenty more sparkle about it than its donor car.

It would be a reach to say this ties up with Audi Sport returning to form, but this SQ5 is certainly good and much more of an S car than Audi’s latest electric cars.

Audi's electric S variants have been a touch meh – more of a trim level with a few nice bits, rather than the toned-down RS experience that we had all come to enjoy. Sure, the S6 E-tron is quicker than the regular Audi A6 E-tron, but with an EV, that's a bit 'so what?'. Plus it has a notably shorter range.

By contrast, the SQ5 is notably different to the regular Q5 and better than it as well in almost every area when you view it through the right lens. If you’re looking for a razor-sharp handling tool that can cheat physics to lap like a sports saloon around the Nurburging, you will remain disappointed. If you’re instead after an all-weather, all-scenario machine that seems to have been developed for you to enjoy everyday drives in a practical and comfortable package, read on.

Advertisement
Back to top

DESIGN & STYLING

7
audi sq5 009

Unsurprisingly, the SQ5 isn't a major departure from the Q5 on which it's based and it's at the subtle end of a sporty makeover. The more outrageous modifications are saved for Audi's RS models.

The new SQ5 largely follows the latest Audi design language. The front features Audi’s ‘Singleframe’ grille and thin lights, while the shoulder-line is typical family SUV.

There’s a very small detail on the new SQ5 that I think means a great deal: the red Audi Sport oblong is back. This oh-so-subtle differentiator could for a very short amount of time be stuck on the back of anything that had four rings at the front. Then Audi got rid of it entirely. Now it’s back on a proper S car.

As standard, all SQ5s get 21in wheels, S badges, red brake calipers and matrix LED headlights. Quad exhaust pipes are another telltale. 

There are some Q-car vibes in how subtle the transition this car has undergone from Q5 to SQ5 has been, but it looks good – sporty but not aggressively so. There's a classiness and civility to the car still, yet with real purpose.

There’s a Sportback model too. This slope-roofed variant was first introduced in 2021 and in continental Europe it actually outsells the regular SUV. Not among us Brits, though. Must be something to do with less space for more money thing going on. 

Admittedly the difference in boot space here between the SUV (520 litres rising to 1473 litres with the seats flat) and Sportback is barely worth mentioning. Basically, if you like the looks, go for it. 

INTERIOR

7
audi sq5 007

The interior is very much like the Audi Q6 E-tron. Up front, there’s a 11.9in Virtual Cockpit (the screen behind the steering wheel) and a 14.5in display (the screen in the middle), while the SQ5 also gets Audi’s Passenger Display (the screen on the passenger side) as standard. 

They’re slick enough to control, with the driver display screen is the most complicated to use with perhaps too many control and display options for its own good when using the steering wheel control buttons. The passenger side screen can be used to alter the nav or radio in real-time, helping the driver, or to watch videos on. The latter of which can’t be seen from the driver’s point of view. No TikTok while behind the wheel, then, thankfully.

The previous Q5's interior had a real air of solidity and quality to it. The new one feels more superficial and generic, with the screens doing too much heavy lifting.

The SQ5 has very few physical buttons. The climate controls are on the big central screen. It gets its own dedicated bar at the bottom, is shown permanently and responds quickly, but it’s still not ideal. Perhaps there's a way to configure it that we never worked out, but to have to go into the menu to adjust the fan speed was frustrating. Yes, you can always leave it on auto, but that function wasn't developed with changeable British weather in mind. At least they’re not haptic like in Audis of old, so you don’t need to press it down hard like you’re trying to delete an app on your phone.

Material quality seems fine - just fine. To our eyes and hands, the tiny little drive selector nicked from a Skoda Enyaq that you pull back or push forward feels cheap and a bit apologetic. The nicest trim comes from the Dinamica microfibre that's dotted around the interior. This feels modern and sporty, and may as well be Alcantara for how it looks and feels. 

The gear paddles are tiny and plastic. They would feel just about okay for a Skoda, but they’re not befitting of a £50,000 Audi and they’re nowhere near the quality we would expect for a £75,000 Audi.

Pull your hand away from the paddles and you will find another peculiarity in the interior: a control panel where you might expect to find the window switches. Those switches are there too but accompanied by quite a few other buttons. Those for the foglights, for instance. This isn’t so bad in isolation, but if you don’t tend to close car doors using their handles, you will end up turning the fogs on – as I and several other testers did.

The window switches also have a strange logic we could never work out, sometimes sending the windows up or down the opposite way to what you would expect.

The sports seats, trimmed in fine nappa leather with diamond stitching, are a real high point of the interior. They feel great: supportive and comfortable. Long distances cause no issue, and the seats are also heated, ventilated and massaging.

ENGINES & PERFORMANCE

8
audi sq5 004

The previous-generation SQ5 was supplied by the black pump, but Audi has seen fit to change it to a 3.0-litre petrol V6 – a 362bhp affair with 406lb ft of torque. 

It’s a great unit, pliable with a wide band of operation and a real turn of pace. Such performance was ever thus with modern fast Audis, which have never really fallen short here, it’s the chassis that have been lacking.

The V6 makes a great sound at start-up, and is far noisier than you would expect at idle, given the way even performance engines like this are tuned for emissions these days.

The torque levels mean that if you want to treat it like a diesel, you can. Lots of low-down pull makes it easy to drive and to drive quickly without using too many revs. It can spin past 7000rpm but peak torque is achieved below 4000rpm.

Its journey to these numbers is linear and non-fussy. It’s not theatrical like Alfa Romeo’s V6 or quite as lovely or as offbeat as Audi’s own five-cylinder engine, but it has its own personality. 

And when Dynamic mode is selected, there’s even a bit of drama with a few exhaust crackles. Sure, it’s as digitally augmented as a Black Eyed Peas song, but it’s subtle enough for it to not be too cloying.

When left to its own devices, the seven-speed dual-clutch gearbox is pretty handy. When the drive mode selector is switched to Dynamic, it changes down quickly and with gusto; in Comfort, it’s less keen to swap cogs. 

Things begin to fall down when you change gears yourself. Pull the left shifter in Dynamic when approaching a corner and you feel the whole car jump forward ever so slightly. It’s a BMW-esque thump in the back that’s supposed to say ‘hey, you’re driving a performance car’, but it can be jarring.

It has a bit of mild-hybrid tech: a 24bhp electric motor on the automatic gearbox and a 1.7kWh battery, which allows for some electric-only running. 

The integration works fine when you’re going but causes a problem when you’re stopping: there’s a bit of a pedal push needed to get onto the disc and the force needed isn’t always the same. The problem isn’t insurmountable, just slightly irritating. Not being 100% sure on how hard to press the brake pedal isn’t great in a car that’s as large and as powerful as this.

You do however yourself driving on electric power more often than you'd expect, particularly creeping around town or in stop-start traffic. It gives the air of a sporty car that isn't 'always on', so you can relax and blend in into a drive without having the car egg you on the whole time. The power is there if you want it, but there isn't a raucousness to it in the background. 

The deal breaker to how it performs comes from left field: the lane-keeping assist function which defaults to ‘on’ every time. It is terrible. Shockingly so. It simply does not work on UK roads, failing to read the correct lane markings and erroneously intervening. That it can easily turned off doesn't excuse it being so bad in the first place.

RIDE & HANDLING

9
audi sq5 008

The best way of describing the SQ5 is like a super-sized Volkswagen Golf GTI. The SQ5 has a well-judged real-world ride and handling balance, backed up by a fast Audi-typical turn of pace, and all while able to remain civilised, refined and comfortable for when you want the miles just to tick by.

Even if it is quite uninspiring, the standard Q5 is still a decent starting point, as a “pleasant and competitive” three-and-a-half star car without any obvious weakness as our road test put it. The Audi Sport engineers have taken that base and made a real unexpected gem.

While it is a very quick car off the line, there is occasionally hesitancy from the transmission when not in its Sport mode. This feels like it can’t decide what to do with the electrical assistance on offer.

Why is it unexpected? Because as the Audi range has increased in size, so too has the amount of S and RS models it offers. The range is so broad, so diverse, that it can be hard to know where the centre of the brand sits, and what a fast Audi really is these days. The numbers always tantalise on paper yet the cars have a habit of falling short on the road.

Key to the SQ5’s transformation is its standard adaptive air suspension. This has enabled the SQ5 to not only ride better than we’ve come to expect S-badged Audis but also improve road holding and agility at the same time.

It hasn't suddenly turned into a Mk1 Porsche Macan in hitting handling heights – a level that no other mid-size SUV maker, Porsche included, has got near – yet it does everything dynamically to a very good standard, and it has been holistically created in a way where you know what Audi’s engineers were trying to do creating it.

Time to return to that GTI analogy: the SQ5 has got character, which manifests itself in its breadth of ability. Like the hot Golf, it will merely entertain rather than excite you on the twistiest B-road, but you will enjoy the 95% of the other miles you do that day more in the process.

The steering is a touch light but feedback is strong. Dynamic mode adds a bit of heft and a bit of feel too. Its surefootedness means you have to go a bit Asbo to have much fun driving it, but fun is possible.

The square steering ‘wheel’ is easy to use on a set of flowing bends, but it's difficult to use on roundabouts, as it almost forces you to not shuffle the wheel at all, which really isn’t ideal.

MPG & RUNNING COSTS

7
audi sq5 001

The SQ5 is expensive to the point that it will always remain a niche choice: it's a £75,000 car. Yet modern cars are pricey, mind; if you go hunting for a similarly conceived sports estate for a point of comparison to the SQ5 and a BMW M340i Touring, the range-topper of the BMW 3 Series Touring range, is nearly £65,000.

Standard equipment is very strong at least; there's little you will want for. On the outside, that includes those 21in alloys, matrix LED headlights, digital OLED rear lights, panoramic sunroof and all the S styling.

My hunch is that if a new RS Q5 comes, it will push it in a direction that the car doesn’t really need to go; becoming faster, stiffer and more raucous won’t necessarily up the fun factor. The SQ5 already feels like a sweet spot.

On the inside, it includes those excellent sports seats, heated rear seats, the interior screens, and heated and automatic everything else seemingly. It's hard to find what it doesn't offer. Sadly, the active lane keeping assistance function is one thing thrown in for free.

You don't buy a car like this for fuel economy, yet on our testing it returned a respectable 32mpg on mixed roads and more than 600 miles of testing. A tank will give a range of more than 400 miles. 

VERDICT

audi sq5 006

The SQ5 is one of the most complete fast Audis this decade. It’s clearly conceived and is full of agreeable improvements over the standard Q5.

The engine is excellent but the real star of the show is the air suspension, which makes for a really comfortable ride but also a sporty and engaging one. The car is better to drive than we were expecting and is a brilliant match for UK roads.

Even in the suspension's firmest setting, I could use it day-to-day. It all feels very connected, well thought out. Comfortable but with enough heft and damping to not make it feel like a burly, two-tonne SUV.

It isn't perfect. It could be sharper still to drive, yet that would come at the expense of some everyday usability. The interior should have greater individuality to that and feel more special for the money, yet it does have some standout features of its own, chiefly the sports seats. And the less said about the lane keeping assistance system the better. 

The mid-size SUV class has a new champion and perhaps its best all-round package; who'd have thought it would be a 362bhp V6?

Murray Scullion

Murray Scullion
Title: Digital editor

Murray has been a journalist for more than a decade. During that time he’s written for magazines, newspapers and websites, but he now finds himself as Autocar’s digital editor.

He leads the output of the website and contributes to all other digital aspects, including the social media channels, podcasts and videos. During his time he has reviewed cars ranging from £50 - £500,000, including Austin Allegros and Ferrari 812 Superfasts. He has also interviewed F1 megastars, knows his PCPs from his HPs and has written, researched and experimented with behavioural surplus and driverless technology.

Murray graduated from the University of Derby with a BA in Journalism in 2014 and has previously written for Classic Car Weekly, Modern Classics Magazine, buyacar.co.uk, parkers.co.uk and CAR Magazine, as well as carmagazine.co.uk.

Mark Tisshaw

mark-tisshaw-autocar
Title: Editor

Mark is a journalist with more than a decade of top-level experience in the automotive industry. He first joined Autocar in 2009, having previously worked in local newspapers. He has held several roles at Autocar, including news editor, deputy editor, digital editor and his current position of editor, one he has held since 2017.

From this position he oversees all of Autocar’s content across the print magazine, autocar.co.uk website, social media, video, and podcast channels, as well as our recent launch, Autocar Business. Mark regularly interviews the very top global executives in the automotive industry, telling their stories and holding them to account, meeting them at shows and events around the world.

Mark is a Car of the Year juror, a prestigious annual award that Autocar is one of the main sponsors of. He has made media appearances on the likes of the BBC, and contributed to titles including What Car?Move Electric and Pistonheads, and has written a column for The Sun.