Why we ran it: To see if the first of a kind for BMW can tackle established rivals as a car not just to drive but also to live with
Month 4 - Month 3 - Month 2 - Month 1 - Prices and specs
Life with a BMW 128ti: Month 4
After a months-long 7500-mile real-world test, it leaves with its head held high despite its shortcomings as a hot hatch - 27 October 2021
My hopes for the 128ti were both high and low, if that is not too contradictory a statement. High because I’ve never driven a ti BMW I didn’t like and I fancied it might find a sweet spot between the standard 1 Series and the expensive, heavy M135i. Low because it was unfortunate enough to be replacing a Ford Focus ST outside my house.
And I’ll say now that as a thing to punt down a decent road, the Ford is better. Wet, dry, night and day, up hill and down dale better. It surprised me not at all that the ti came last at our Junior Handling Day – only that it was invited in the first place.
But the thing with long-term reports is that we’re not too concerned with all that stuff. I’m lucky enough to live in the Welsh borders, where I can be on a cracking road within three minutes of getting in the car, and even I don’t spend much time door-handling whatever I happen to be in. Because, like you, I spend most of my time behind the wheel on motorways, or in town, and who gives a stuff about yaw gain following lift-off oversteer there?
I care rather more that the car is quiet, which the ti is once you’ve learned to ignore the low- rev, part-throttle body boom, and comfortable. And in that regard, the 128ti is excellent: fine seats and just enough spring rate to control the body over crests and in dips without introducing any harshness.
The engine, however, is only so-so. Actually, its fuel economy was extremely impressive and I appreciated its ability to return a genuine near-50mpg at a steady 70mph motorway cruise – not bad for a 155mph car fired by petrol.
But it’s not an enthusiastic engine and cannot be made so even by the surprisingly responsive eight-speed auto ’box. It lacks both the power and character of the Ford’s punchy motor, denying it access to the hot hatch top table, even if its limited chassis abilities had not done so already.
But here’s the thing. I am really picky about what I choose to drive and not once was it anything other than genuine pleasure to know I had a long journey ahead of me in the BMW, because all the stuff that really matters in such situations it has covered.
Join the debate
Add your comment
So it turns out BMWs first front wheel drive hot hatch, isnt a hot hatch at all, just a decent car. If only they hadnt stuck the Ti bagdes on it, to disapoint people.
And even though it isnt a hot hatch, it would still be better if it came with a manual option.
I find it strange that the reviewer complains that the 128ti fuel tank is too small, then praises how economical the car is.
It has a 10.8 gallon capacity, say 9 for safety margin, giving a range of 360 miles at 40mpg or 450 mpg at 50mpg. How much more range do you need in the UK?
Also, having now run three cars with this engine, it does indeed get more economical between 6-10000 miles, and rarely averages less than 40mpg in mixed driving thereafter.
Personally, I would have the BMW over the Focus because of its interior and technology alone. Never mind that it feels altogether a more complete and refined package, and you can delete the badges and trim bits if they offend.
There was a time when you would buy a reasonably quick BMW for its understated almost Q car looks, it shows how low they have stooped when it now out "Halfords" a Fast Ford..