7

Mini’s modern-day Maxi has genuine driver appeal and SUV-aping credentials - should you snap one up for £7k?

Find Used Mini Countryman 2017-2024 review deals
Used car deals
From £7,490
Other Services
Sell your car
84% get more money with

The first modern-era Countryman set out to prove that Mini could break away from its supermini roots and make a practical five-door hatch, but in reality it was short on performance, ergonomically flawed and a little lacking in character.

Nevertheless, the BMW Group marque’s crossover became its most popular model and that warranted a successor, which landed in 2017 with a roomier cabin and a grippy, well-balanced drive that put it well among the best in its class – and now you can have one for less than £7000.

Adding 200mm to the length of the chassis meant the second-generation Countryman, or ‘F60’ in Mini speak, had SUV-aping credentials, making it more capacious and practical than its predecessor.

Adults won’t feel aggrieved in the back (there’s more head room than in a Mk7 Volkswagen Golf), although they will find more comfort if the middle seat isn’t occupied.

There’s plenty of luggage space behind them too. In fact, its 450-litre boot could rival that of cars from the class above.

Mini aimed to add more refinement and material richness to the interior, and while this was largely successful, we still had some reservations about the fit and finish.  

But it was an advance over the models beneath it, with improved seat adjustability and softer cushioning to help move it on ergonomically.

Talking of which, we would urge you to find a car fitted with the upgraded Navigation Pack. This increased the screen size from 6.5in to 8.8in and allowed for touch and rotary dial control, which makes it a doddle to use on the move.

Advertisement
Back to top

The nav system is great, too, and the screen itself graphically strong and well configured.

But while much of the Countryman’s character is reflected by its upmarket cabin, it is on the road where the car’s real personality shines through, mimicking the spirit of its more vivacious hatch sibling.

Sure, it doesn’t offer the same level of dynamism as a compact premium hatch from Audi, Mercedes or Volkswagen, but it steers with enough pace and incisiveness to feel agile and willing.

It also handles impressively with plenty of balance and grip to make it engaging through corners.

This comes at the expense of comfort and isolation, though. The body is prone to fidgeting on uneven B-roads and the fairly noisy ride lacks some cushioning over lumps and bumps. Optional adaptive suspension improves its composure but makes little difference overall. 

The engine line-up ranged from the entry-level 134bhp 1.5-litre petrol triple to 2.0 litres and four cylinders in the diesel 148bhp Cooper D, 187bhp Cooper SD and 189bhp Cooper S petrol.

All versions came with the option of All4 four-wheel drive, barring the sportier 228bhp JCW.

You could also have four-wheel drive with the plug-in hybrid Cooper SE All4, but we would steer clear, given its disappointing economy and smaller boot.

If you’re a high-mileage driver, the volume-selling Cooper D is the way to go: it is a little lazy at lower revs but has more than enough punch for daily duties, and can do over 40mpg.

Urban and sub-urban dwellers will find the 1.5-litre petrol is more than up to the task, with its thrummy three-pot well suited to the Countryman’s character.

Look past the car’s iffy ride and you have a practical and extremely likeable five-door that delivers on driver engagement and technology.

As long as you keep things simple with a basic pack (Chili or Comfort are best) and smaller alloys, the versatile Countryman might just be all the car you need – and for under £7k, who can grumble with that?

Back to top

RELIABILITY

Is the Mini Countryman reliable?

The second-gen Countryman can hold its head high when it comes to reliabilty. Indeed, it is not totally free of mechanical gremlins, but it did well in What Car?'s Reliability Survey, finishing sixth out of 22 cars in the small SUV class, with an impressive 97.7% overall score.

As a brand, Mini did even better, finishing third out of 32 manufacturers, and was only beaten by Lexus and Toyota. 

Engine: Crankshaft sensor failure can put the car into limp mode, limiting performance. Take the car on a decent test drive to ensure it’s running smoothly.

An oil leak or vibration from the engine could be a symptom of engine mount failure. The lower mount is typically the culprit and a new mount is the only cure.

The B47 diesel is more robust than its predecessor but still suffers from timing chain issues, where it can stretch or snap. It’s a big fix too, as the engine needs to come out to access the chain. Some diesels suffer from DPF- and EGR-related issues but these are less common.

Turbo issues aren’t unknown and the wastegate actuator is the main source of most of them.

Body: Ensure the electric tailgate opens and closes properly as the struts or actuator motor can fail, meaning it opens only halfway or, in some cases, not at all. Replacing these parts will sort it.

Sunroof: Water in the boot or footwell could be a leak from the sunroof. The drain holes can become blocked and leak water into the cabin. Check the history of the car for such an issue and have a good rummage inside for any signs of damp.

Interior: Heated seats can stop working. Ensure they warm up properly and the light comes on when you push the button. If they’re not working, a new fuse or heated seat control module will fix it.

An owner's view

Jason Morris: “I bought my second-generation F60 Countryman in early 2017 to replace my Mk1 Countryman, which I had been using for trailer training. I used my F60 for driver training for six years, covering over 200k miles, many of those spent towing a 1200kg trailer. It’s coped with everything I’ve thrown at it. Sure, it’s had a few parts along the way, but nothing that you wouldn’t expect to wear over time. Last year, I retired the car but decided to keep it because I just really enjoy driving it.”

Also worth knowing

In 2020, Mini gave the Countryman a light nip and tuck, with new bumpers, headlights, tail-lights and front grille.

Originally, Mini didn’t offer the Countryman with set trims but it later decided to simplify matters by moving to three core specs – Classic, Sport and Exclusive – in 2018.

You could then add optional packs, which brought different levels of equipment and functions. The Chili Pack adds dual-zone climate controls and LED headlights, but if you want heated seats and parking sensors, go for the Comfort Pack.

The 2017 Countryman gained a five-star Euro NCAP safety rating, scoring highly on adult and child occupant safety.

DESIGN & STYLING

Mini Countryman badging

The Countryman was offered in various four-wheel-drive versions, arriving with a bit more ground clearance than the average five-door and could be optioned with a roughty-toughty, SUV-apeing bodykit. 

It was more of a crossover hatchback judging by the square-cornered, faintly macho styling.

And yet stand next to the second-gen Countryman and you could see what Mini’s decision to split the difference between a five-door supermini and a Nissan Qashqai-sized soft-roader actually amounted to, and we’d defy you to conclude that it was anything other than a typical family hatchback.

Being 200mm longer than the car it replaced, at almost exactly 4.3m long, and less than 1.6m tall, the Countryman had the dimensions to fit that description. It had a little more head room than the average Volkswagen Golf-sized five-door, though, as well as a quite generous 450-litre boot.

Engines ranged from a 1.5-litre three-cylinder in the entry-level petrol Cooper and hybrid Cooper S E derivatives to 2.0 litres and four cylinders in the more powerful Cooper S, Cooper D diesel and Cooper SD diesel.

You could have anything from 134bhp to 189bhp under the bonnet. A 228bhp John Cooper Works model topped the range while a four-wheel-drive Cooper S E with a combined output of 218bhp and rated for sub-50g/km CO2 emissions provided a hybrid alternative.

There was also the volume-selling, 148bhp Cooper D which could be had with front- or four-wheel-drive. You could also choose between a six-speed manual and an eight-speed torque converter automatic gearbox.

The Countryman was suspended independently at both axles; unlike most of them, it was available with adaptive dampers (dubbed Electronic Damper Control, or EDC) to broaden Mini’s usual highly strung dynamic character for a more mature clientele.

INTERIOR

Mini Countryman interior

Mini aimed for a more materially sophisticated, practical and refined feel for the mk2 Countryman, and the effect of which was best described as ‘bubbling under’ in the busy, chromey, idiosyncratic but not quite uniformly well-finished cabin you'd find in the car.

The grey cloth trim was sombre for a Mini (as was the piano black trim over much of the fascia), but it was wrapped around front seats that offered more adjustment than those of the firm’s lesser models, as well as a little bit more cushioning than Mini’s habitual standard.

There was plenty of head room, too, and for a Mini, this was certainly progress towards the comfort and versatility of a ‘normal’ five-seat hatch – more of it, anyway, than the Mini Clubman offered.

The back seats afforded less opportunity for adjustment, and yet there were three child-sized seats here or plenty of room for two adults if you prefer, thanks to a bench that could split and slide forwards and backwards. 

Even by the standards of practical and considerably more prosaic family five-doors, such as the Skoda Octavia and Vauxhall Astra, the Countryman’s interior space wasn't likely to disappoint.

Its hand remaimed strong in the boot, with 450 litres of space on a level with the load lip, a roomy bit of storage underneath the false floor and back seats that at once reclined at various angles and also folded 40/20/40.

The Countryman Cooper D came with a colour navigation system and DAB radio as standard, so, unlike some of the brand’s other models, it wasn't in need of further expenditure. The Media Pack was a popular upgrade for the car, however, combining enhanced Bluetooth with wireless charging, Mini Navigation XL and Mini Connected XL. 

Spending the extra enlarged the infotainment screen from 6.5in to 8.8in and, for the first time in a Mini, you got touchscreen input as an alternative to the rotary ‘touch controller’ that any Mini or BMW driver would be used to.

The touchscreen options were displayed at a useful scale and were easy to navigate, and you would often end up switching menus and radio stations that way because it was easier than reaching for the iDrive-style rotor. 

The audio system was strong and clear, Bluetooth phone pairing was easily done, call quality was good and the satellite navigation system was excellent. In other words, you'll want to make sure a used car has this fitted to it. 

As for standard equipment, the Mini Cooper models came with 16in alloy wheels, front foglights, automatic wipers, heated wing mirrors on the outside as standard. Inside there was air conditioning, a leather-clad steering wheel and Mini's Visual Boost infotainment system complete with Bluetooth and USB connectivity, DAB tuner and sat nav.

Choosing a Cooper S variant added a twin chrome exhaust system, manually adjustable sports seats and 17in alloy wheels. The Cooper S E hybrid model included charging cables and unique software for its infotainment system.

Topping the range was the Countryman John Cooper Works model, which came with a beefy bodykit, sports suspension, 18in lightweight alloy wheels, LED headlights and half leather upholstery.

A variety of packs were also available, including Chili and JCW Chili. The former added part leather upholstery, added storage areas, front heated sports seats, climate control, LED head and fog lights and larger alloys.

ENGINES & PERFORMANCE

Mini Countryman side profile

The Mini Countryman’s big-volume diesel was fairly strong for its type.

It whipped the car up to speed pretty smartly and recorded some competitive numbers despite having to contend with low temperatures, what was probably an above-average kerb weight and a not especially aerodynamic body.

The Countryman’s engine wasn’t quite as flexible as that of the Mazda 3, needing almost two and a half seconds more to cover the same acceleration increments in fourth gear.

On the road, the diesel’s response was a little bit lazy and non-linear at lower revs but seldom felt weak or unwilling. It did sound and feel a little gruff and noisy, though.

While we’d just about agree that the Countryman was probably a touch more refined than an equivalent Mini Clubman or even a regular five-door Mini hatch, it wasn't a refined car compared with other mainstream hatchbacks.

The car’s idle wasn’t too bad, but it allowed three decibels more noise into the cabin than the Mazda at 30mph and two decibels more at 50mph, and that was enough to notice.

Plenty of wind and road noise was evident at higher cruising speeds, as well as the engine noise.

On cabin isolation, Mini could plainly have done a bit more to ensure the Countryman felt more grown-up than its rangemates.

The car’s controls were consistently weighted and pleasant to use in the main, while its brakes were strong and delivered decent pedal feel.

The notable exception, however, was the notchy, fussy action of the six-speed manual ’box’s gearlever, which baulked too often on the trip between ratios and generally required too much of your attention – and a bit too much in the way of elbow grease – to make for a relaxing town drive.

RIDE & HANDLING

Mini Countryman cornering

The Countryman ought to have been the closest thing to a luxury car Mini had made.

Okay, that's a bit like saying the Spruce Goose flying boat was the closest thing to a submarine ever built by the Hughes Aircraft Company, but it illustrates the point about the Countryman.

If Mini was ever going to show us it could balance its trademark darting dynamic energy against some more supple compliance, a smoother ride and a more surefooted feel than it usually managed, this was it.

Had all that been achieved? Well, partly.

Not far enough to make this car feel like anything other than a sporting option among softer and more stodgy medium-sized five-doors, even in bottom-rung diesel, non-sport-suspended, front-wheel-drive form – which, we’d concede, was probably all well and good.

But neither was it far enough to give Audi, Mercedes-Benz, Volkswagen or Volvo a serious fright that Mini was about to start vacuuming up customers out of the ‘compact premium’ automotive mainstream.

The Countryman wasn’t quite that comfortable, quiet-riding or easy to rub along with.

It steered well, with pace and incisiveness just striking enough to make the car seem agile and willing, and with decent on-centre stability, precision and feel. It handled with a vigour that was rare among other full-sized hatchbacks and only matched once you’re well into warm hatch territory.

Level, direct, tenaciously grippy, balanced and encouraging through corners, it was the last car you’d label as a pseudo-SUV if you’d been blindfolded and put in the driver’s seat.

However, the comfort and isolation the average driver would want from the ride of his everyday-use hatchback wasn't quite present.

It wasn’t in the Mini Clubman, either, but the fact that Mini had again missed the target while having the Countryman’s extra wheel travel to take advantage of was more of a disappointment.

It rode more than well enough to avoid annoyance while you’re enjoying the keenness of its handling, but there was little lope or cushioning either in town or out of it.

Body control was fidgeting and excitable over uneven B-roads, while the coarse roar given off by its run-flat tyres over rougher surfaces made it a tiresome car in which to travel when you were not in the mood to be entertained.

The Mini had a stepped electronic stability control system that was subtle enough even when left fully on but could be switched half out (into Dynamic Traction mode) or fully out.

You could leave it on and still drive the car up to the limit of grip without feeling too many interventions; switch it off and there was a bit of adjustability to the handling on the limit, although not quite as much as you got in smaller Minis. 

MPG & RUNNING COSTS

Mini Countryman

The engines were all fairly efficient. Mini claimed 62.8mpg and 118g/km of CO2 from the manual with 17in wheels, but the Countryman wasn’t class-leading.

Our tests recorded an overall 41.9mpg, but reported that the car may have emptied its particulate trap during the test, which would adversely affect the economy.

An expectation of around 45mpg as a daily average was respectable, then, but not brilliant.

VERDICT

3.5 star Mini Countryman

The Mini Countryman was a complicated car and not at all the textbook crossover we expected it to be.

You could undoubtedly grow to like it, but that affection was more likely to come about if you bought into the retro-cool ‘new premium’ design and zappy driver engagement on which Mini was known for. 

If you do embrace it, you may decide that only a Countryman will do, particularly against its less tigerish and quirky mid-sized premium hatchback rivals.

It wasn't quite the bullseye classy crossover we envisaged, however. 

The art of developing an outstanding full-size hatchback is in expertly balancing obliging comfort against enough dynamism to keep you interested in the driving experience.

Mini came close to nailing that compromise here than it did with the Mini Clubman, but the Countryman was still a way off being the broadly impressive, sophisticated prospect it needed to be to bring new buyers into Mini showrooms, rather than simply preventing the old ones from leaving.

With all this in mind, the Countryman only managed to enter into our top five in fourth place ahead of the Mercedes-Benz A-Class, but behind the Volkswagen Golf Alltrack, Audi A3 Sportback and the BMW 1 Series.

 

Mini Countryman 2017-2024 FAQs

Is the MINI Countryman available as a plug-in or electric?

Yes it is. The MINI Countryman was the first plug-in hybrid from the British brand, and shares its petrol-electric powertrain with parent firm BMW. Comprising a 1.5-litre three-cylinder petrol engine that drives the front wheels and an electric motor that powers the rear axle, it develops 217bhp and can carry the Countryman nearly 32 miles in EV mode. There’s no currently all-electric option - if you want battery power alone you’re limited to the much smaller MINI Electric hatchback.

What are the main rivals for the MINI Countryman?

With its rugged over roader looks and family hatchback-sized body, the MINI Clubman is every inch the compact crossover. The closely related BMW X1 packs the same premium appeal and engines, but is a little more comfortable and spacious. It’s not as upmarket, but the SEAT Ateca is just as good to drive, while in Cupra guise it matches the high performance Countryman John Cooper Works for power - as does the Volkswagen T-Roc R. The Mercedes GLA is more expensive, yet delivers greater refinement and more hi-tech features.

How much power does the MINI Countryman have?

There are four engine options for the MINI Countryman - all of which are turbocharged petrols - starting with the 134bhp 1.5-litre three-cylinder Cooper. The PHEV plug-in hybrid uses the same unit but combines it with an electric motor to deliver 217bhp - that’s more than the 2.0-litre four-cylinder in the Cooper S, which serves up 175bhp. At the top of the Countryman range is the high performance John Cooper Works that uses the same engine as the Cooper S, but tuned to deliver 302bhp and a 0-62mph time of 5.1 seconds.

What choices of gearbox are there for the MINI Countryman?

Despite a relatively limited engine line-up, the MINI Countryman has a surprisingly wide selection of gearbox options. A slightly notchy six-speed manual is standard on Cooper and Cooper S models, while a slick-shifting seven-speed twin clutch automatic is available as an option. The plug-in hybrid is fitted exclusively with a six-speed torque converter automatic transmission for the front wheels and single-speed reduction gear for the electric motor that’s mounted to the rear axle. Finally, the John Cooper Works also gets a traditional auto gearbox, but here it has eight gears, as in the mechanically identical BMW M135i.

Where is the MINI Countryman built?

Despite its heavy British branding, the MINI Countryman isn’t actually built in the UK. Most European models are constructed in the Netherlands, at the Nedcar factory that was originally constructed to build cars under the Volvo and Mitsubishi joint venture, before then being turned over to make the first generation Smart ForFour and Mitsubishi Colt. The Countryman is also assembled by BMW India in Chennai, at the Gaya Motor facility in Jakarta, Indonesia and at the Inkom plant in Malaysia.

How many generations of the MINI Countryman have there been?

The Countryman has proved to be a popular addition to the MINI line-up and is now in its second generation. The original car made its debut in 2010 and was effectively built on a bespoke platform, which it later shared with the quirky Paceman three-door coupe crossover. The current car arrived in 2016 and is based on the BMW UKL2 platform, which it shares with the BMW X1, X2 and 2 Series Active Tourer.

Matt Saunders

Matt Saunders Autocar
Title: Road test editor

As Autocar’s chief car tester and reviewer, it’s Matt’s job to ensure the quality, objectivity, relevance and rigour of the entirety of Autocar’s reviews output, as well contributing a great many detailed road tests, group tests and drive reviews himself.

Matt has been an Autocar staffer since the autumn of 2003, and has been lucky enough to work alongside some of the magazine’s best-known writers and contributors over that time. He served as staff writer, features editor, assistant editor and digital editor, before joining the road test desk in 2011.

Since then he’s driven, measured, lap-timed, figured, and reported on cars as varied as the Bugatti Veyron, Rolls-Royce PhantomTesla RoadsterAriel Hipercar, Tata Nano, McLaren SennaRenault Twizy and Toyota Mirai. Among his wider personal highlights of the job have been covering Sebastien Loeb’s record-breaking run at Pikes Peak in 2013; doing 190mph on derestricted German autobahn in a Brabus Rocket; and driving McLaren’s legendary ‘XP5’ F1 prototype. His own car is a trusty Mazda CX-5.

Mini Countryman 2017-2024 First drives