From £35,1758

Hybrid power marks a welcome return to form for the Hyundai Santa Fe rival

When we last road tested an X-Trail, it was 2014 and small-capacity diesel engines were all the rage. Thanks to the hybrid drivetrain, today’s X-Trail has a lot more power on tap.

But our e-Power e-4orce (which means it has four-wheel drive) test car's big hybrid battery also adds a lot more weight: Nissan claims 1886kg and our test car even tipped the scales at 1947kg.

If you want to tow, you’re best off with a five-seat mild hybrid, because it’s rated for 2000kg. The 4WD full hybrid isn’t bad either, at 1800kg. The seven-seaters can tow slightly less, and the front-drive full hybrid can pull only 670kg.

Despite that weight, the X-Trail e-4orce sped to 60mph in just 6.6sec – 4.6sec faster than the diesel from nine years ago. More to the point, it’s considerably quicker than the hybrid versions of the Sportage (7.3sec) and the Sorento (8.5sec) and the Toyota Highlander (8.5sec). It’s not even that far behind the vRS version of the Kodiaq (5.9sec).

Clearly, the hybrid X-Trail offers more than enough performance. More important is the way the car delivers it, and that’s where hybrids can often come unstuck, with wailing CVTs and awkward handshakes between engines and motors. Nissan makes the bold claim that e-Power provides the “EV-drive feeling without the need to recharge”.

The X-Trail gets very close indeed, making it a more pleasant system than Toyota’s. Because the wheels are only ever driven by electric motors, power is generally instant, linear and very quiet. The engine is often running to top up the battery, but it must be smothered in insulation because you wouldn’t know.

Advertisement
Back to top

It doesn’t completely carry off the EV sensation. Ask for more than, say, 75% power or repeatedly demand strong acceleration and the engine will need to start working harder to generate enough energy to power the motors and keep the battery topped up. At this point, it will maintain a high RPM and you will be able to hear it in the cabin. It’s not an unpleasant noise, and there is enough power in reserve that most of the time you can do without that last 25%. If you floor the throttle in one go, it will take a second before the drivetrain delivers full power, but equally, 80% is plenty for any situation.

Another upshot of the X-Trail’s mechanical layout is that it has regenerative braking just like an EV. As standard, there is very little regen effect when you lift off the throttle. Engaging ‘B’ mode on the drive selector increases it noticeably and pressing the e-pedal button makes it even stronger. It’s very intuitive but you’ll still need the brake pedal to come to a complete halt. Thankfully, that is very progressive as well, making smooth stops a doddle.

For those on a tighter budget, we also tested the slightly cheaper mild-hybrid X-Trail. It employs the same engine as the e-Power model but uses it to directly drive the front axle via a CVT, rather than as a battery generator.

In practice, the two-tonne mild-hybrid X-Trail drives well, offering decent engine responsiveness, if not the same immediate torque as its e-Power sibling. The CVT is also fairly smooth, if slightly laggy at points, especially when significantly more power is called for, such as when overtaking or merging. Its accelerator pedal has more resistance and its brakes are a tad less snappy at lower speeds.