Earlier this week, a faithful reader from Australia called Darren contacted us with an enviable problem – he can’t decide whether to buy a like-new condition Renault Mégane RS 275 Trophy-R or a brand new Toyota GT86.
This is easy, I thought. Both are fantastic cars, but you’d have to have the hot Mégane, right? I mean, it’s essentially a front-wheel-drive Porsche 911 GT3 and financially speaking, it’s going to be the one to appreciate.
But then I paused, pondering the purity of a front-engined, rear-wheel drive sports car. Surely, my conscious countered, if the prospect of appreciation were ignored, the GT86 would be the more natural choice for a driving enthusiast.
My heart was almost sold on the GT86. Then I remembered a comment said a few years back in the office of Evo Magazine, my previous employer, where Autocar contributing writer Dan Prosser also used to work. After a stint on circuit in some of the year’s hottest hatches, he asked “why would you ever need rear-wheel drive when front-drivers handle like that?”.
Those words reverberated with me when I had my first stint in a 275 Trophy-R. At the time, it was the most focused road car I had driven, yet it was also one of the most approachable. It had ultra-responsive steering guiding the sharpest chassis I’d encountered, all to the soundtrack of the turbocharged 2.0-litre engine’s distinctive ‘blast furnace’ voice – a byproduct of the remnants of 271bhp being channelled through an AkrapoviÄ exhaust.
Join the debate
Add your comment
Two Fantastic Cars
Tough choice, until you see the interior of the Renault. Buckets and harnesses please!
I bought a BRZ
I chose the BRZ. I was coming from an Integra Type-R so fancied going back to RWD, loved the proportions of the BRZ (still do), test-drove one and liked it.
The Renaultsport Megane was the other car on my list. I tried to get a test-drive in one, but failed, as they were only available from Renaultsport dealers. Who knows, I might have preferred it!
After 4 enjoyable years, I'm am trading the BRZ for a new Civic Type-R.