The best first cars for new drivers - driven, rated and ranked

Our recommendation: Toyota Yaris T-Sport

This car was so typically Japanese and one of the last words in unconventional motoring.

When the regular Toyota Yaris arrived, it became Car of the Year thanks to its novel attention to detail, which means the flagship T Sport was built on bedrock foundations.

Less solid are its looks: it hasn't aged quite as well as some others on this list. But it does have some exterior touches to make it look both interesting and endearingly odd at the same time.

Much like the interior, then. The air vents are like pastry cutters, there are huge pockets carved into the dashboard to store your clutter and where you'd expect to see an instrument binnacle there's just plastic, because it has been moved to the left a bit (of course it has!).

By contrast, the engine wasn’t that weird: it's a 1.5-litre atmo petrol. But it was one of the first to have variable valve timing, which enabled it to push out 103bhp and attain a 0-62mph time of 9.0sec. Power was sent to the front wheels via a five-speed manual - the only transmission on offer.

Our recommendation: Fiat Panda 100hp

Picture a Fiat Panda driver and you’ll probably think of a jolly pensioner on their way to pick up the week’s milk and bread. But your nan’s shopping cart this is not.

In true hot hatch tradition, Fiat transplanted the 1.4-litre overhead-cam engine from the then-new Grande Punto into its tiddly city car and eked an extra 5bhp out of it, for a total output of 99bhp.

That gives it a surprising turn of pace in real-world conditions because the car weighs a scant 975kg and it has a six-speed gearbox to keep the revs up. 

Its cheeky character is backed by the reworked styling, with an expansive Audi-style front grille, flared arches at each corner, and a dinky spoiler at the back. 

These were remarkably good value for money on the second-hand market for years but have recently achieved cult status so values are climbing. Expect to pay anywhere between £1000 and £6000, with restoration candidates on the lower end and low-mileage collectors’ cars on the higher.

Insurance is rated at group 11, making it one of the most affordable sporty cars to run as a first-timer.

But heed this warning: you need to buy one very carefully, as the number of bespoke parts on the 100HP can make it a nightmare when things go wrong. The rear beam axle, for example, is liable to rust and snap around the springs. It wasn’t used on any other car, and Fiat didn’t build very many 100HPs, so finding a replacement is tricky.

Likewise, you’ll want to be protective of the bodywork. The bumpers are made from recycled plastic so can be tricky to repair – some body shops will outright refuse to attempt a fix – and replacements cost around £400 each on the second-hand market.

But get a good ’un and you’ll own one of the most charismatic small cars of the past 20 years, which you can fully exploit without risking your licence or safety.

Our recommendation: Suzuki Swift Sport

You might not realise it, but the Suzuki Swift Sport is probably one of the archetypical hot hatchbacks - just like the Peugeot 205 GTi or Ford Escort XR3i.

They all have one thing in common: they're normal hatchbacks with a small amount of spice to give them a tasty kick. The Swift Sport, for example, has a 1.6-litre engine and produces 125bhp. It dispatches 62mph in 8.9sec and has a top speed just shy of 124mph. 

Fairly reserved figures, then – but remember that it weighs just 1.1 tonnes, which makes for a hugely attractive power-to-weight ratio if you've just passed your test and need to convince the insurers you know how to drive a car.

The price of used examples is equally reserved, both to buy and when you're going through the insurers. Being in group 23, it's in a slightly higher group than others on this list, but it's still at the lower end.

Our recommendation: Ford Fiesta Zetec S

The Ford Fiesta was always going to make this list. It doesn't matter which spec, which year or which price you get one for: beneath a pretty handsome shell lies a fine-handling chassis by which the competition was historically judged for nearly 50 years. You could even go so far as to call it the Porsche 911 of superminis.

The best part is that you can pick one up for pennies. You should, however, buy carefully. Some cars will have been tastelessly modified, and steer clear of cars that look ragged and neglected because you will probably end up paying for more in maintenance than you did for the car.

The very fact that they're favoured by anyone from those who like to drive quickly to those who can't drive at all means insurance costs can get quite steep if you modify them, particularly in expensive areas such as London.

Choosing a car isn't so complicated, because there are loads of examples to go around. The most common engine available is the 120bhp 1.6-litre petrol, which pushes it to 62mph in a little under 10sec with a snappy five-speed gearbox.

Our recommendation: Seat Ibiza Ecomotive

The genius of the Seat Ibiza is that it blends a youthful fit and feel with complete ubiquity. People can drive something that isn’t too staid, all good in the knowledge that there are thousands of models on the used market to choose from. This makes it cheap to buy and among the cheapest cars to insure in the UK.

The exterior looks pretty sporty, but up front you will find low-powered engines that provide low running costs. Do a lot of motorway miles? We recommend going for the 1.4-litre diesel. It struggles less at speed than the low bhp petrols and will offer better MPG in this real-world application. Officially, it can get up to 80.7mpg.

Inside, it’s pure Volkswagen Group, in that it’s pretty bland but largely well put together. Plus, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto may be available, depending on which model you go for, giving you simple and instant access to apps such as Google Maps.

Our recommendation: Renaultsport Twingo GT

The Renaultsport Twingo is often hailed as one of the finest junior hot hatches ever, but it’s the slightly milder GT that you might want to turn your attention to as a new driver.

That’s because the GT sits in insurance group 17 rather than the RS’s 20, making it a slightly more realistic prospect for your first car.

It’s quite nippy too, with a turbocharged 1.2-litre petrol engine sending 99bhp through the front wheels in normal use. Stamp on the throttle in second, third or fourth gear, though, and it’ll overboost for up to a minute at a time, yielding 104bhp.

The Twingo GT is a light car, at 980kg, so it accelerates with surprising verve and handles decently in spite of its soft suspension set-up.

Around £2000 is enough to get you into a decent GT that hasn’t been to the moon and back, making it exceptional value for money in the current car market.

Our recommendation: Citroen Saxo VTR

Sure, it’s a throwback to the bygone days of stuffing superminis with more ’woofer than Crufts, but the Citroën Saxo VTR still stacks up as one of the best entry points to performance motoring.

It has an older version of the 1.6-litre four-pot found in the C2 VTR, pushing out 90bhp. That might not sound very powerful, but it’s only got about 900kg of metal to cart around, so feels surprisingly potent on the open road.

This also plays in its favour in the twisties, where the Saxo can provide an entire education in lift-off oversteer.

Just beware that safety isn’t the car’s strong suit. It was rated at just two stars for occupant protection by Euro NCAP back in 2000, and anti-lock brakes weren’t standard on the VTR either.

You should also buy very carefully. The Saxo was a modder’s favourite back in the day, so plenty were fitted with questionable modifications – and you’ll have to declare any such changes to your insurer, likely incurring considerable costs.

They’re also plenty old enough to suffer from rust. Common problem areas are the rear axle, sills and wheel arches, but give the whole car a thorough check to be on the safe side.

Prices range from £2000 for a leggy car to £7000 and beyond for the best-preserved examples. The Saxo’s well on its way to modern classic status, though, so values are rising fast.

Our recommendation: Citroen C1 VTR+

Now, which self-respecting enthusiast is going to turn down such competition and plump for the no-frills, boggo Citroën that looks as interesting as bathwater and uses technology developed in tandem with the Gregorian calendar?

Well, those exact reasons are why you should buy one. Think of it as a blank sheet of paper – a cheery starting point for what could become anything you want, from a low-rider to a reliable tool for the uni commute. Or even a race car.

You can buy a conversion kit from a specialist site for £3700 that allows you to convert your bichon frisé into a track-ready pitbull. They look great if they've been modded well and don't cost a fortune to fix, because you won't need to spend that much on buying one in the first place.

It’s also slow, with just one litre of engine capacity. But what you lose on swings, you gain on roundabouts. It’s a joyous car to drive – playful, unintimidating and ready to take a beating.

It can be picked up for even less money than the Fiesta above, and insurance is just as cheap, because it's in group three - one of the lowest on this list.