Roll-on subs: Monthly subscriptions work for streaming music, but what about cars?

“Some customers choose to have a convertible in summer and a 4x4 in winter,” says MacDonald. “FlexiFleet suits drivers doing over 12,000 miles a year. If they’re doing less than that, leasing is probably cheaper. At the other extreme, for someone doing 24,000 miles, FlexiFleet is certainly cheaper.”

Thrifty buys the cars it rents (it’s the UK’s biggest purchaser of BMWs) and after six months is keen to sell them on, which is why most of them are premium brands in high specifications, fitted with desirable options. The cheapest car it offers, at £324 per month including VAT, is a Mini Cooper Classic 3dr and the most expensive, at £2268, a BMW i8 convertible. Wright’s Mini costs £380 per month and his X2 £536. Because he’s renting two cars, these prices include a 5% discount.

Wright heard of FlexiFleet through a friend, a professional rugby player, just as his lease on an X5 was ending. Sam liked the concept and since he’d just invited his girlfriend to relocate from Spain to the UK, decided to sweeten the move by treating her to a new BMW M4 cabriolet through the rental company, at the same time renting a Volkswagen Golf GTI for himself.

Shortly after, the couple bought a puppy that – as puppies are wont to do – became much larger, so Wright swapped the M4 for an BMW X2. When his Golf was sold at six months, he replaced it with a Mini Cooper S, which he plans to change for a Range Rover Sport in time for Christmas.

How does a FlexiFleet deal compare with leasing? For a BMW 320i Sport auto, FlexiFleet quotes £550 per month including VAT, maintenance, breakdown, road tax and 2000 miles per month. The deposit, which is refundable, is also £550 and the rental arrangement can be terminated at any time without penalty after one month.

There are many leasing providers and readers should shop around for the best rates but, at random, we approached First Vehicle Leasing and asked it to quote for the same model on two, 24-month deals with maintenance – one based on 15,000 miles a year and the second 24,000.

On 15,000 miles, FVL required an initial rental of £1915, a broker fee of £198 and 23 monthly payments of £638. On 25,000 miles (the closest figure to 24,000 miles the company could quote), it required an initial rental of £2180, a broker fee of £198 and 23 monthly payments of £727. The customer is locked into the deal for the duration of the term.

FlexiFleet is much cheaper, at least in these comparisons, although bear in mind that its rental charges can change outside the agreed booking period. In addition, customers may find their usual motor insurer is unwilling to insure their FlexiFleet car. Most mainstream insurers do not insure rental cars and even ‘driving other cars’ cover excludes them.

Still, in these uncertain times, tracking down a favourable insurer may be a job some drivers will think is worth the effort if the prize is greater motoring flexibility.

Car subs: your flexible friend

Car subscription services are a way of getting a car for a low but non-refundable deposit (some call it a joining fee) followed by monthly payments (called subscriptions) that include a mileage allowance and maintenance. Most providers also include insurance.

Drover is a leading subscription company that supplies new cars and used ones up to four years old. It has 3500 customers, 80% of them hiring nearly new cars. Customers pay a one-off joining fee of £179 with their first subscription and agree to hire the car either on a month-to-month basis or for fixed periods of three months, up to a total of 24 months. Generally, the longer the term, the lower the rate. If a customer wishes to cancel, they pay 20% of the remaining contract value or a minimum of one month’s rental. The monthly mileage limit is 800.

“Our typical customers are someone who has started a new job and is uncertain about their future, and a 28- to 32-year-old looking for a new and simpler car ‘ownership’ model,” says Matt Seakins, chief marketing officer at Drover.

Cars include a 2018-registered BMW 520d M Sport, which booked for three months costs £862 per month and £840 per month for nine months, while a 2018-reg Toyota Aygo X-Play on the same terms costs £326 and £291.