The first thing that catches the eye are the standard 15in rims, with skinny 175/65 R15 low rolling resistance tyres. They make the car look as if it is using four emergency replacement wheels: a bit of a car stylist’s nightmare, really.
Open the door and the One doesn’t look cheap at all, however. All materials used in the cockpit are as good as the ones found in the more expensive Cooper and Cooper S variants and there is no shortage of switches in the centre console or trademark toggle switches.
The car we drove had some optional extras fitted, including a sports leather steering wheel with cruise control and Mini Driving Modes. This allows the driver to choose from Green, Mid or Sport modes. Each modifies accelerator response, steering effort and engine acoustics and, unlike similar systems in other cars, here you can actually feel the difference.
Choose Green and the circular centre console flashes a green arc and the engine gets notoriously less responsive, but never to the point of feeling sluggish. In the instrument cluster, fitted to the steering wheel column, appears a scale indicating how many range 'bonus' miles the driver won by driving in a economy-friendly way.
Change to Sport and the three-cylinder engine comes alive, without ever sounding like a typical three-pot. The engine note is surprisingly pleasant, with a roaring sporty sound.
Press the accelerator and the One feels more rapid than the 0-62mph figure of 9.9sec might suggest. The torque curve starts to rise from very low revs and delivers a convincingly swift response across a wide range of engine speed.
The gear change is a true joy for the keen driver. This new six-speed manual performs great automatic rev matching on downshifts, which the driver can override if they apply some well-judged heel and toeing. Fifth- and sixth-gear ratios are a little long, to save fuel when driving on the motorway, where wind noise is not as low as it could be.
And we come back to those skinny tyres. True, city driving is not affected by them and motorway fuel consumption actually benefits. But turn onto a B-road to exploit that famous go-kart-like Mini handling and soon the tyres start to come up short in terms of road holding and precision. Tyre degradation even becomes an issue, when the tyres start to bend, under heavy cornering.
Join the debate
Add your comment
The car in the photos
That's absolutely fine Mr
Oh dear!!!
I was just interested in reading a review of the basic 3 cylinder engine.
Most people who buy this car will end up paying more than they would like because of the extras situation that BMW almost force on their customers. Sad but true.
I'm off to Pistonheads.
Mr Burt wrote: Most people
Could be wrong, but I'm pretty sure BMW don't "force" anyone to buy extras, almost or otherwise. But it is true that most people who buy this car end up paying more than "they would like", as most people would like to pay as little as possible (if not nothing) for a car, any car, not just Mini.
Not necessarily so...
Well, when visited our local MINI dealer to order our new F56, the sales executive spent well over an hour taking us through the options, but applied no undue pressure to specify anything we didn't want or need. We found the experience unexpectedly pleasant and relaxed, and ended up with exactly the car we wanted. I've no idea how typical or otherwise our experience was, but thought I might put the case for the defence... However, I do agree that Autocar should push for test cars closer to standard spec... the MINI One pictured has so many extras that I'm sure it would cost significantly more than our Cooper.
Know your audience
This car will be brought by people who want style and economy, not racing drivers.
Over specced cars for the press release that do not reflect the base car or represent the car the above group of people will buy.
I took time to read this review just to get an understanding of the base model and kill 10 minutes. Now I am just annoyed.
Articles like this are the reason I stopped buying autocar some time ago.
If it's not the latest top line German car with 500bhp it's 'reviews' like this that are irrelevant to the potential customer. I'm out!!!